Taking a Moment for the Game of Thrones Finale

May 20, 2019


I have been a devout fan of Game of Thrones since the very beginning. I’m not just talking about HBO, I mean I-read-the-books-hardcore-fan.  I have felt love, I have felt loss, but I have never felt disappointment until HBO took over and released George R.R. Martin to the wind.

My analysis is simply the humble opinion of an English teacher who specializes in fantasy literature.

What HBO did right:

  • Personified Drogon with a depth and breadth of understanding that Daenerys never had. By burning the Iron Throne after Jon killed Dany, Drogon demonstrates his comprehension that the root cause of his mother’s death, his brothers’ deaths, and all of the suffering, was the quest for power. Drogon, of all the characters, illustrates the insight that power leads to corruption.
  • Making Sansa the Queen of Winterfell. If any character has shown a consistent growth, it has been Sansa. Her character development has been steady, with solid basis and anecdotal evidence to all lead her to that place. Lady Sansa has earned her keep as the Queen of the North, and while we can argue Bran’s blessing is nepotism, his near-omniscience makes us believe he has a greater understanding.
  • Samwell Tarly as Grand Maester is the precise payoff Sam has earned through his studies and character development. He has grown through plight, found his way to bravery, and continued to honor and value the pursuit of ethical knowledge above all. His precise balance of intellect and morality will make him ideal for the position.
  • Brienne’s dedication to Jaime. As much as they did Jaime wrong by making him fall back into the arms of Cersei, it’s not poor character development, it’s just because we (as the audience) hoped more for him. In truth, though, Jaime’s self-loathing is a flaw he has struggled with from the beginning, and the only consistency for him has been Cersei, while the main consistency for Brienne has been honor, and they both illustrated that to the very end.
  • Turning Daenerys into a villain. I know this is not a popular opinion, but what discerns heroes from villains is how we deal with hardship. Dany lost her claim to the throne, Jorah, Viserion, Rhaegal, and Missandei – any person would be completely heartbroken by this incredible loss over the last two seasons, but what would have distinguished her as a true leader and a rightful queen would have been to react with compassion and mercy, just as Jon said. Freedom is never bought without casualties, and as Tyrion explains, we cheered her on as she destroyed “the bad guys,” but a leader who continues to destroy her trusted advisers simply because they are advising her against bad decisions is no longer a leader, but a tyrant. A good leader, a leader of people, allows herself to be checked and questioned, to be open to different ways of doing things, and mostly, to know when she has made a mistake. Tyrion perfectly illustrates that Daenerys developed a god-complex over her unwavering philosophy.
  • I’m so glad Ghost got his hug. That killed me two episodes ago.
  • Bran as King of the Six Kingdoms. Bran was definitely a surprising choice for most people, but a brilliant one. It was Bran’s push from the tree which essentially sparked the entire series. It was Bran’s dagger to lead to the death of the Night King. It was Bran’s strange journey to becoming the Three-Eyed Raven which allowed the truth about Jon to be revealed (and essentially, the truth about Daenerys).  A man who knows suffering, a man who knows survival, a man who knows the history of the realm, and an omniscient-like wisdom – as illustrated when he tells Jon that Jon was “exactly where he was supposed to be” – and the son of Ned Stark, arguably the most beloved character of the series. Bran makes perfect sense and will be a wise, just ruler… if Jon was also by his side.
  • Tyrion as Hand-of-the-King.  Yes, Tyrion has made mistakes, but there is not one mistake he made that he didn’t learn from. All we can ask from an excellent adviser is intellect, reason, ethics, morality, and mostly, reflection
  • Ser Bronn of Blackwater and of Highgarden… the story of how a lowly, low-life sell-sword can become the Master of Coin. Comic relief done right.
  • Arya heading West of Westeros… I don’t know if I hate this or love it. It is befitting of her character, as she was never content to live the life of a “lady,” but it almost feels empty. I think many of us feel cheated not knowing about the “green eyes” part of her prophecy, but I still put this in the “done right” category because there is absolutely nothing conventional that could have been justifiably given to Arya’s conclusion, so it was best left up to imagination.

What HBO did wrong:

  • They really did Jon dirty. No one even MENTIONS the fact that Jon is the TRUE heir to the Iron Throne at the end of the episode. Listen, we get that the Unsullied, Dothraki, and Dany-fans wouldn’t love what Jon did, but if Drogon could understand, then everyone else should have, too. And Tyrion, who essentially talked Jon into killing Dany, really should have spoken up for him. Not a word, a mention, meanwhile Jon risked himself advocating for Tyrion to Dany before he killed her. Only Sansa apologizes for not being able to do more for Jon. ONLY SANSA! Seriously, what do we learn from this? The man with the most respect and honor in the entire series has to kill BOTH of his lovers, get killed by his men, and then get ostracized by the very people he saved, all the while HE IS THE RIGHTFUL HEIR. I get not making Jon the King, but it should have been proposed to him to which he says no.  Tyrion is, and always will be, my favorite character, but Jon should have been the one to suggest Bran.  Jon knew what Bran went through. Jon knew he had to protect Bran. Jon and Bran always had a deeper connection for a visceral truth of the realm. Jon should have been given the right to suggest Bran, Bran made King for all the reasons presented in the show, and Jon made as one of the advisers because he served the realm on so, SO many other levels.   Not only was sending Jon back to Castle Black just wrong considering he was instrumental for saving the world, why the heck do they end with him wandering off North with the Wildlings? They just make him disappear from existence?
  • Where are Viserys’ “little birds” and raven notes to save Jon?  Why show us that he put those wheels in motion to never call back to them? There should have been some mention of it to have given his final days legacy and purpose.

I would love to hear your thoughts in the comments! Feel free to Tweet me @scentsthemoment, too.

Kristen Fusaro-PizzoPresident

Leave a comment

Also in Scents the Moment Blog

The Final Moment

July 04, 2019

Yesterday, we made the big announcement on social media that we will be closing down Scents the Moment. Together, we have helped rescue so many dogs and cats with Staten Island Hope Animal Rescue and Twenty Paws Rescue. You were with us as we adopted Lucy, the rescue pittie. You were with us as we … Continue reading The Final Moment

Continue Reading

What’s In Your Soap?

April 09, 2019

I don’t ride bandwagons or hype-trains. I was never one to tout “all natural” or “organic” because it was trending. So, several years ago, when I started my research into making my own soap, it was out of the sincere need to help my husband’s struggle with psoriasis and eczema. At that time, prior to … Continue reading What’s In Your Soap?

Continue Reading

April 2019 Contest & Sweepstakes!

March 31, 2019 1 Comment

  Place an online order and ONE product gets placed in the purse and YOUR name gets entered into the sweepstakes! Place as many orders as you would like throughout the month for multiple entries. Only eligible for ONLINE orders. The winner receives the purse PLUS all of the goodies inside! Winner will be called … Continue reading April 2019 Contest & Sweepstakes!

Continue Reading